… in the Minneapolis Star Tribune notes that the most charitable description of what’s been going on at the clubby University of Minnesota medical school would be “bizarre.”
Friday, October 12, 2007
Competition, crossing disciplines produce innovative medical research
Today's Pioneer Press carries an OpEd piece by Dr. Frank Cerra, provost of the Academic Health Center at the University of Minnesota.
It is good that a public dialog is starting to develop about the direction of University and the Academic Health Center.
The original Pioneer Press article that Dr. Cerra complains about actually reports the work of a local Health Partners researcher, Brian C. Martinson, who explains his concerns in a commentary in Nature, arguably the leading journal of general science in the world.
Mr. B. has previously posted on this situation: "Another Indication that More NIH Funding Is Not Going to Solve BigU Medical School's Problems.."
Dr. Cerra and other parties interested in this situation, crisis is not too strong a word, might wish to consult this post. It might be useful for the Pioneer Press to solicit a response OpEd from Brian C. Martinson for a fuller explanation of our current problems and the reason why more money from NIH isn't going to solve them.
Ciao,
Bonzo
Thursday, October 11, 2007
Brewer vs. Bruininks: The Aftermath
(and Kudos to Mr. Maturi)
Mr. B. posted Sunday on the pulling of a football "scholarship" at BigU, based on an article in the Daily and comments from a letter writer. He has had some luck in raising issues on the website Mnspeak (www.mnspeak.com) that has some rather odd conventions of what constitutes a legitimate post. Apparently it is ok to put up some links for the post, in fact this is encouraged. But linking something of your own is not supposed to be done, except for rather vague circumstances, i.e. the moderator decides.
A post on the Science Classroom situation that cited only an article in the Pioneer Press was deemed appropriate and generated a good discussion (50 posts) of the issues involved.
An attempt to post on another issue was deemed inappropriate. Unfortunately, the only way you can determine that the moderator does not like the post is that it never shows up on the main board. An attempt over the weekend to introduce the football scholarship issue was, apparently, unsuccessful so the issues was raised on a Gopher athletics site, the Gopher Hole . There again a reasonable discussion ensued over the matter. On Monday, however, the Mnspeak post magically appeared. A reader complained about a link to the Periodic Table and Mr. Bonzo noted that he had no objection to the post being pulled as the issue raised had already been discussed elsewhere. This happened.
Summary: Both Mnspeak and the Gopher Hole seem to be reasonable places to post on issues of University of Minnesota interest. The GH is obviously for athletics only. Don't post either place if you have thin skin. The rules for posting on Mnspeak seem to be a little ambiguous, but that gives the moderator some discretion, which is fine.
Communication: Mr. B. sometimes sends emails to University people in connection with his posts. It seems like dirty pool to ask OurLeader questions on the blog, without giving him the opportunity to know they are being asked. He is, of course, free to ignore both emails and posts.
Over the week-end Bonzo missives went out to administrators, regents, politicians, and the AD, Joel Maturi, to whom Mr. B. has not been particularly kind on the PT.
Whatever else you might say about Mr. Maturi, he is not an artful dodger concerning emails. And he must be one of the hardest working people at the U. I heard from him late at night and at 6:30 in the morning. He also presented in detail the Athletic Department's side of the story without consulting a spinmeister or hemming and hawing, or worrying about what I might do with his reply. By the way, I don't plan on doing anything with his emails. They are private as far as I am concerned. I only use material freely available to anyone with access to a web-browser, such as newspaper articles, web-site postings, or blanket emails. Something written in haste and in good faith in an email should not be used to embarrass a person or to try to make them look stupid.
The only other person in BigU's administration who is in Mr. Maturi's class as far as communication goes is Frank Cerra. I have dissed Dr. Cerra in the PT plenty. But if you send Frank an email you will get a response from him, personally and very quickly if he is in town. If you want to see him personally he will arrange this quickly, even if it is at seven in the morning. I am always amazed that Frank will do this, as busy as he is; other administrators, who will go nameless, have communications directors or chiefs of staff who deal with the hoi polloi - you will never get anything directly from them. Kind of reminds me of my time at 3M. The good managers and even Technical Directors would actually come down to the lab and talk to the peons. This kind of thing doesn't happen (enough) at BigU. Our administrators, Dr. Cerra excepted, are too busy trying to emulate what they think are acceptable business practices.
Ciao, Bonzo
Wednesday, October 10, 2007
Sobering News for BigU or,
Show Me the Money and Then We'll Talk Greatness...
Mr. B. has previously posted extensively on the disconnect between available resources and the "ambitious aspirations" of our administration to become "one of the top three public research univerties in the world [sic]."
See for example:
"Oh, Lord, It's Hard to Be Humble when you have ambitious aspirations"
Or
"Can BigU Become Great Big U?"
Further evidence of reality problems at BigU is reported today in the Pioneer Press.
(I thank a colleague for bringing this article to my attention.)
University Of Minnesota / U lags in race for U.S. research money
Paul Tosto
University of Minnesota leaders have agonized for years about the competition for federal research money. On Friday, regents will see more evidence the U is slipping in that race.
Federal research spending by the university rose about 39 percent between 2000 and 2005, but the University of Michigan saw its funds rise 52 percent and the University of Wisconsin jumped 71 percent in the same period, data from the U's latest accountability report show.
Regents will review the reports Friday when they meet on the Morris campus for their regular meeting. They'll also meet that day with university president Robert Bruininks and research vice president Tim Mulcahy to discuss financing the university's future.
Mulcahy declined substantial comment but said when he talks to regents Friday, he'll summarize recent data that "suggests that we are beginning to close the gap."
[Dr. Mulcahy, OurLeader, and Provost Sullivan should fear the clock as did Captain Hook. The general trend is downward and from Mr. B.'s worms-eye view, nothing dramatic seems to have happened around here at BigU, in fact the bureaucracy seems to have gotten worse. As Oliver Twist would say: "Please, sir, more vice presidents?"]
The U gets funding from many state and private sources, but the federal government is a key source. For those worried about the U's place in the research race, the accountability report offers some sobering news:
while the U is still a major force in federal research spending, its funding from 2000 to 2005 grew more slowly than the 10 other institutions it considers its peers.
Federal nondefense research and development spending declined at the U between 2004 and 2006 after a decade of growth, a trend that will have a "profound impact" on the U's ability to grow its research operations, the report says.
Earlier this year, though, U economists concluded that Minnesota as a state had stumbled among states in the chase for academic RD money. That report, ominously titled "Long Gone Lake Wobegon?" argued that research spending in the 1970s helped fuel decades of state prosperity and that losing the money race to other states could create problems.
Had it kept pace with the University of Wisconsin-Madison, for instance, the university's research funding would have topped $1 billion in 2004, twice the actual amount, the economists' report noted.
Eventually, the University community, the legislature, and the citizens of ColdState are going to have to have an honest dialog about the future of the university. The sooner, the better.
Ciao,
Bonzo
Sunday, October 7, 2007
Or, Stiff the Student-Athlete After You Think It Is Too Late for Him to Do Anything About It
Or, Millions for Coaches But We Can't Afford a Football "Scholarship" for an Academic All-American Who Lettered Last Year
Business As Usual at BigU?
Bonzo has previously ranted on the pitiful graduation rates of revenue producing athletics programs at BigU.
We learn from the Daily:
Without a scholarship, that only intensifies.
"It can't realistically be done without the financial help," former Gopher football player Brody Grandas said. "It's tough to throw the burden of all that on your parents."
A senior studying business management and communications, Grandas joined the team as a first-year without a scholarship and quit this season for financial reasons after his scholarship was not renewed. Grandas said he is 30 credits away from graduation.
After learning that his scholarship was not going to be renewed, he spoke to head football coach Tim Brewster. Brewster told him there were no scholarships available, Grandas said.
The football team currently has 81 scholarship athletes, Dan Wolter, University spokesman, said. The maximum scholarships allowed are 85 for football teams, according to NCAA rules. [So it would appear that the U has room to give the kid a scholarship?]
Before last season Grandas was awarded a "one-year renewable scholarship," which was "based on performance" from former head football coach Glen Mason, Grandas said. He appeared in 10 to 15 plays per game last season and earned a letter.
He also appeared in the Gophers' first game this season against Bowling Green, Grandas said. But after practice the following week he was told his scholarship would not be renewed.
Information about Grandas was erased from the Gopher sports Web site the same day he quit, he said.
Grandas said when he spoke with Brewster, the coach told him he'd love to continue to have him on the team, but with finances, if it wasn't a realistic option then he wished him the best. [Can you imagine a coach making the money that Brewster does, telling a kid that finances were a problem? ]From the comments section in the Daily for this article:
Greek Gopher from Chicago, IL writes: Well written article, but I found out a couple additional facts that I found very interesting in just googling Grandas' name.
Grandas was an academic All-Big Ten selection last year.
To earn this award you must earn a Big Ten letter by playing in a certain amount of plays and hold a high GPA as well.
Minnesota Football ranks 10th (2nd to last) behind Michigan state in graduation rate. The Gophers are at an alarmingly low rate of 49% graduation rate (Star Tribune Oct. 3rd, 2007).
Brewster's choice of not renewing Grandas' scholarship does not make sense to myself when Grandas contributed last year on a team that is significantly better record wise.
Also Brewster clearly stated in the article that he had no intentions of renewing Grandas' scholarship but wanted him on the team.
Why did he not give Grandas fair warning about this decision so Grandas could align arrangements to help pay for school?
The article stated Grandas was given warning after the first game of the season, a game that he ironically played in.
So it looks as if business proceeds as usual in the BigU football program. OurLeader, as a member of the NCAA leadership on athletic/academic issues, bears personal responsibility for this kind of behavior.
Dr. Bruininks, are you sincerely interested in the graduation rate of Gopher athletes and do you approve of Brewster's behavior in this matter?
This is sick.
Bonzo
Friday, October 5, 2007

The Re-writing of History Continues at BigU
Mr. Bonzo has previously posted on OurLeader's propensity for re-writing history:
"Remember when the geniuses tore down the poor old decrepit - on campus - Memorial Stadium and replaced it with something they now admit was even worse...the downtown Metrodome? And now we're going to replace the downtown Metrodome with? Twin City Federal Stadium, which of course will be right back on campus near... the old Memorial Stadium location."
"Which goes to show that if you wait long enough as a U of M administrator, people will eventually forget your past sins and you can feel free to re-write history. (I was a very strong supporter of the new Science Classroom Building. There is no conflict between teaching and research. I am for stature rather than ratings. I strongly support General College. I strongly support a higher minority enrollment. General College must go. I am against re-engineering. I am for Kotter's Eight-Stage Process of Creating Change. This is a land grant institution.)"
This unhealthy behavior continues with respect to OurLeader's remarks on the strike that recently appeared in a Q & A in the Minnesota Daily.
Although I am reluctant to bring up the strike because of the bad feelings that it will cause, I have decided that this is necessary because the behavior exhibited in this matter by OurLeader is an excellent example of the lack of transparency, openness, and sadly honesty, that has been demonstrated in so many different ways since we first began the administration directed drive "to become one of the top three public research universities in the world [sic]." It is arrogant and patronizing, implying that people, including faculty, do not know the nature of institutions such as Berkeley, Michigan, UCLA, or Cambridge or Oxford, for that matter. The administration's stated goal causes most faculty to roll their eyes and throw up their hands in frustration.
For an older piece on ambitious aspirations, please see the post:
{Executive summary: Get real!}
OurLeader is called out by a fellow faculty member:
Given the administration’s generally hamfisted handling of the strike, however, I wasn’t at all surprised to find Bruininks dishing out more platitudes and propaganda. Disappointed, yes. But not at all surprised.
Bruininks claims that his childhood in a union household taught him that “no one, absolutely no one, wins when you have a strike.” But if he’d really learned that lesson, he’d have given AFSCME the same deal he gave the Teamsters. Not “something close” or “essentially a comparable proposal,” but the very same deal.
Bruininks’ description of the administration’s offer to AFSCME “essentially a comparable proposal” to the Teamsters deal is a fine display of propagandistic “weasel words.” It sounds well and good to say these are “comparable” offers, but all that really means is that it’s possible to put them side by side and consider their similarities: not that they’re actually equivalent to one another — much less that such a comparison would demonstrate a rough equivalence between them. By the same token, it’s possible for me to compare “President Bruininks” to “a weasel,” but the mere fact that I can do so doesn’t actually mean that Bruininks is a devious, thieving vermin — much less that such a comparison is fair to the weasel.
Bruininks also speaks compassionately about “reach[ing] out to our employees to see if we can heal whatever wounds are out there.” But he wasn’t interested in showing any such compassion or generosity when AFSCME workers asked for a living wage: he offered them a substandard deal and then refused to budge. He wasn’t interested in healing any wounds when faculty, students, and staff told him — over and over again — that his failure to settle the strike was hurting the University: he simply sent a few form letters to a tiny fraction of the University community who expressed such concerns, and then dismissed the rest of those dissenting voices as “noise.”
I find it appalling and hypocritical that President Bruininks can attach a message to the CFD brochure expressing his desire for faculty and staff to “join [him] in this great tradition and contribute what [we] can” to “the needs of the state and its citizens” when he has so callously turned his back on the legitimate needs of the AFSCME workers who are such a vital part of the University community.
But it is nothing less than galling for President Bruininks to ask faculty and staff (and most especially staff) to embrace a spirit of generosity that he is clearly unwilling to apply to his own management of the University: less than 0.1% of the University’s budget, after all, could have been reallocated in ways that would have averted the AFSCME strike completely.
When President Bruininks can “walk the walk” of giving generously to the community in ways that match his ability to “talk the talk,” I will happily consider giving to the CFD once again. In the meantime, however, my financial generosity will continue to go towards the AFSCME strike fund.
After all, if I’m going to donate a portion of my paycheck to the community — and I’m happy to do so — I’d prefer to share the wealth with people who clearly understand what the word “community” really means. And the University administration’s behavior these past few weeks is a clear indication that too many people in Morrill Hall simply don’t have a clue.
OurLeader is called out by a Teamster:
Prez says what?
In the October 3rd article "A Q&A with Bruininks," Bob Bruininks pointed to the Teamsters contract as proof that what he offered AFSCME employees was a fair and equitable contract. As a teamster I voted no on this offer but I know many did not vote at all for going on strike was not an option, for under the current leadership electing Osama Bin Ladin as homeland security director would make more sense. Many Teamsters supported AFSCME fully. For Bruininks to claim a workforce demoralized or impoverished to the point where striking is not an option as proof of our satisfaction is just one more example of the dishonest and arrogant way this administration (human resources) does business. I felt in fairness and honesty I needed to respond to these statements.
Michael G. Kelly
University Teamster
STILL LAGGING
A comparison of the University of Minnesota Graduation Success Rate (GSR) figures in key sports compared to Big Ten rivals and the national average for all Division I programs, according to NCAA data released Wednesday.
Sport/ GSR /Big Ten rank/ National GSR avg
Football /49/ 10 /65
Men's basketball /38 /11 /61
Women's basketball /67 /11/ 81
Men's hockey 43/ *5 /84
*Only five Big Ten teams field men's hockey teams.
The GSR rates are six-year graduation rates for athletes entering school between 1997 and 2000. The GSR, unlike federal graduation data, takes incoming and outgoing transfers into account.
So by this measure both the men's and women's basketball team graduation rates are last in the BigTen. This is indeed disappointing. Football is next to last and men's hockey is last, although only five schools still play hockey. I am sure that OurLeader will be taking all necessary steps to see that we are at least in the middle of the pack in the BigTen in these areas, especially because of his direct involvement in the NCAA in a leadership role. He could start by raising the academic bar for enrolling athletes, but then however would we fill Twin City Federal Stadium aka the House that Jack Built?
Athletics and the 'U'
The Oct. 4 Star Tribune neatly sums up what's wrong with the University's athletics department: failure to improve the academic performance of our alleged student athletes and their continuing and embarrassing alleged misbehavior off the field.
How long are students, faculty and taxpayers going to put up with total mismanagement of the athletics department by President Bruininks, his rubber stamp Board of Regents and the incompetents in the athletics department? (Not to mention the thousands of brain-dead alumni and bored, idle-rich, self-appointed de facto assistant athletics directors called "boosters.")
Please tell me which is the bigger joke: the pipe dream of returning to the Rose Bowl or becoming a top three research university? And which relates directly to the University's primary mission and which is totally extraneous?
When is the Minnesota media going to take a serious look at the role of athletics at the University and help the public and our government officials explain why millions of our taxpayers' dollars are being wasted on a new football stadium when they could be put to good and proper use in so many ways benefitting academics?
If only we could stop the stadium and channel those precious dollars into academics.
Willard Shapira
University alumnus
The athletic graduation rate is a disgrace. Claiming that things are improving is of little solace. We should demand that these numbers place the U at least in the mid-point of the BigTen with a time stated by which this goal will be attained. No more excuses. OurLeader bears direct responsibility for this situation. It can be fixed and certainly will not be detrimental to our pitiful won/loss record, at least in football. Mr. B. used to naively think that our athletic programs had such bad records because we had such high academic standards. Little did I know...
The University of Minnesota is already a great university in many ways. Let us set as our goal rising again to respectability in the BigTen based on commonly used performance metrics. When the top BigTen public universities are mentioned, let them be Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota.
Let's also commit to being the best land grant university possible - with all the implications of this goal - for the people of the state of Minnesota. I invite the Administration and the Regents to join the faculty, staff, and students in this effort. It is time for OurLeader to get down from the horse and walk with the rest of us.
The smokescreen of becoming "one of the top three public research universities in the world [sic]" has got to stop soon or our remaining seed corn will be destroyed.
Ciao, Bonzo
Thursday, October 4, 2007
Two BigU Faculty Members Move On
Ernest Retzel, PhD: U of M -> National Center for Genome Resources
Anne Taylor, MD: U of M -> Columbia University
According to an email from Dean Powell, Dr. Anne Taylor will be leaving the U on November 2:
|
| date | Oct 3, 2007 10:49 AM |
|
| subject | From Dean Deborah Powell |
Dear Colleagues,
Please join me in extending best wishes to Anne Taylor, who is leaving Minnesota to return to her hometown of New York City and the position of vice dean for academic affairs at Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons. Her last day here will be Nov. 2. During her seven years here, Dr. Taylor has served our Medical School as associate dean for faculty affairs, as renowned researcher, and as professor of medicine.
Deborah E. Powell, M.D.
Dean of the Medical School
Mr. B. asked a colleague about Dr. Retzel and was surprised to learn that he had left during the summer and is now a program leader at the National Center for Genome Resources. From the NCGR web site:
Ernie Retzel has worked in informatics since 1989. During this time, he worked on several plant EST and genome projects, including /Arabidopsis/, soybean, pine and /Medicago truncatula/. Bioinformatics efforts have included developing databases for legume projects, as well as forest crops [poplar and a variety of conifers]. Prior to joining NCGR, Retzel was the founder and director of the Center for Computational Genomics and Bioinformatics at the University of Minnesota, and led bioinformatics development efforts under a variety of NSF, USDA and private grants and contracts. Development work included software for visualization, data mining, protein families and distributed computing.
Wednesday, October 3, 2007

"U profs call new science building too experimental
Article on the above topic in today's Pioneer Press
(6:14 pm - there are now 40 comments on the article on Mnspeak.)
Daily Throws President Bruininks Softballs
Interesting topics are raised but followup is weak.
Discussion of these two articles will follow in due course.
Ciao,
Mr. Bonzo - in the words of Robert Kvavik, the university's associate vice president for planning - a whining dinosaur
Sunday, September 30, 2007

Spread Far the Fame of Our Fair Name (apologies to NU)
Graduation Rates Again Under the Spotlight
Everyone at BigU knows that we have serious problems with graduation rates. As was reported lately: " Professor Sirc said he talked to Dr. Howard, Director of Institutional Research, about what would be the single best measure to improve the University's rankings; Dr. Howard said it would be to improve the graduation rate."
A website devoted to college admissions reports:
Two economists at William and Mary will be publishing an article that they think improves on the "overperformance/underperformance" in US News.
Here is the link to a draft of the article:
http://www.wm.edu/economics/wp/cwm_wp24.pdf
They compare graduation rates after adjusting for four things:
(1) SAT 25th percentile
(2) percent of freshmen in top 10% of HS class
(3) percent of faculty who are full-time
(4) expenditures per student
They ranked 187 schools based on how well they exceed expectations in getting students to graduate. They produce a "technical efficiency" score for each school that tells the actual graduation rate divided by the expected graduation rate (determined by the four inputs above). For example, a technical efficiency score of .95 means that the actual graduation rate is 95% of the expected graduation rate.
This is, in effect, a ranking based on "value added." How well do schools do given the students they enroll?
Unfortunately, this method indicates again that there are some severe deficiencies at BigU with respect to graduation rates as our ranking and that of some neighbors is indicated below, as well as that of some of our competition:
1 Indiana University Bloomington 1.
1 Pennsylvania State University 1.
1 University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign 1.
39 University of Wisconsin Madison .995.
47 Northwestern University .985.
49 University of Michigan in Ann Arbor .981.
56 Michigan state University .973.
92 Purdue University West Lafayette at .916.
94 University of Iowa .914.
140 Ohio State University Columbus .837.
179 University of Minnesota Twin Cities .700.
Ouch!
Our closest competitor in the BigTen is Ohio State, the other BigTen Megaversity. But they are nearly 40 slots above us. A gap of more than 40 separates OSU from the rest of the BigTen. With the exception of Minnesota and Ohio state, the BigTen performance by this measure seems pretty respectable. Particularly interesting are the outstanding performances by Indiana, Penn State, and Illinois. There are certain geographic similarities in those institutions, but clearly having an outstanding football team does not seem to correlate with this measure of graduation rates.
So here we are again, folks. Last in the BigTen in graduation rates. Brushing this off by saying "we are improving" will not cut it. There IS literally no place to go but up - we are 179 out of 187 schools studied. Institutions clobbering us include: Universities of Kentucky, Oklahoma, Mississippi, Wyoming, Idaho, Toledo, Montana, Miami [sic], Missouri, etc., etc., ad nauseum. There is something fundamentally wrong here that needs to be attended to before we should be dreaming about being one of the "top three public research institutions in the world [sic]." The Science Class Room situation, posted on earlier, is just another example of the unreal world in which our administration seems to live. Tearing down large classrooms - required for efficiently processing the large introductory courses that are necessary at a BigU - and not replacing them is wrong-headed, especially in opposition to faculty who are actually using the present Science Classroom Building.
While the Gophers are in Indiana next weekend, maybe OurLeader and ET (Indiana Law is his alma mater) should go down a day early and talk to the folks in Bloomington about how they do so well with graduation rates? Then next Saturday they could cheer on the Gophers, in whom they have so much invested.
Ciao, Bonzo
Thursday, September 27, 2007
The Natives Are Restless, or
Does BigU Have the Money to Fulfill Our Ambitious Aspirations?
Minutes*
University of Minnesota Senate Committee on Finance and Planning
Tuesday, September 18, 2007
* These minutes reflect discussion and debate at a meeting of a committee of the
Tuition Increases on the Horizon
Will the Regents support a 7.5% tuition increase, Professor Martin asked? They have been told it is part of the budget plans, Mr. Pfutzenreuter said. Professor Chapman suggested that 7.5% will be seen as quite high. Mr. Pfutzenreuter agreed but pointed out that for Minnesota residents the legislature provided funding to buy down the increase by 2%, so it will only be 5.5% (for students from households with an income of up to $150,000). Professor Chapman said he was sorry to see such an increase in an election year; Mr. Pfutzenreuter said the other choices are increased state funding or less new investment.
Austerity at BigU
Professor Chapman inquired of Mr. Pfutzenreuter if, based on his experience, this will be perceived as an austerity budget. Between the tuition increases and the cuts, it looks pretty austere to him, he said. Mr. Pfutzenreuter said it is austere.
Professor Martin said there is no sense of this coming austerity in the University community after all the discussion about how much support the legislature provided for the biennium. This will be a big surprise, she said.
Professor Martin reminded Professor Konstan that while the University can get rid of a college, it cannot get rid of the faculty, who hold tenure in the University. It seems, however, that the University has closed units and not saved money, Professor Konstan said.
Later, Professor Konstan asked whether the universities it seek to join--top public institutions like Michigan and Berkeley--share Minnesota's model of continuously squeezing units. Does this squeeze really lead people to think efficiently, or does it just add stress that saps productivity?
Mr. Pfutzenreuter said he had proposed the approach of putting the burden on the cost-pool owners. Last year they were told to talk to their customers; this year they have an obligation to reduce costs or find more productive ways to do business—and not, for example, by closing four libraries. At some point almost all at the University will say there is nothing more that can be done more efficiently, Professor Martin commented, and people may be close to that point now—and cannot respond in a rational way to directives for greater efficiency.
More generally, Professor Konstan asked, is $8.5 million in reallocation providing more advancement of the University towards the top-three goal than the amount that University-wide agonizing, stress, and wasted effort over these cuts moves it away from the goal? Mr. Pfutzenreuter agreed that the University may be trying to invest too much in new programs or activities
UMorePark – Gold Mine or Money Sink?
He has been asked a number of times how to pay for this, Dr. Muscoplat related; the goal is to make a lot of money for the University that would be captured in an endowment to support University's academic mission, but it must spend some money to make money. There is several million dollars set aside for UMore Park; there are options for funding, including the mineral rights for the gravel and hiring a developer to sell land, for example. He said he believes the University can finance the project, but at this point they have only a vision, not a plan.
Dr. Muscoplat said he has talked with Dean Bailey about whether the University could develop a different educational system at UMore Park. The question is how to get there; it will not happen at the academic level without resources, such as research assistants and faculty lines. Any plan can be futuristic and scholarly, Dr. Muscoplat said, but if it does not make money for the University, it will not be built.
There is a lot of benefit to the University to invest in real estate as a growth vehicle; the Harvards of the country are doing it. That is a political decision that the Board of Regents must decide, Professor Martin said, but the University does not have a good record as a landlord.
Discussion
With respect to the top-three goal, if the University does not have the financial foundation to make it work, it is unwise to pursue the goal. Only the Academic Health Center has said what it needs to get into the top three, which is 500 additional faculty and new space for them. CLA could say that it needs 200 additional faculty but it has no place to put them. Ambitions may be outranking the ability of the University to achieve them.
Professor Konstan said it would help to identify what the top-five institutions do, whether they have continuing stress. If they have financial stability, the University is in a losing game.
Tuesday, September 25, 2007
For some reason, Mr. B. receives numerous blanket emails of minutes from various BigU committee meetings. Almost every time he reads one of these, interesting things jump out. I have previously posted on the Science Classroom Building. Many of the other issues raised seem worthy of some sort of dialog. But our administration continues merrily along, safe in the knowledge that they know best. I wonder? Tid-bits below.
From Minutes
University of Minnesota Faculty Consultative Committee
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Caveat:
"These minutes reflect discussion and debate at a meeting of a committee of the University of Minnesota Senate; none of the comments, conclusions, or actions reported in these minutes represents the views of, nor are they binding on, the Senate, the Administration, or the Board of Regents."
Faculty Discipline?
Professor Durfee, although unable to be present at the meeting, had sent an email message about the strike; he suggested the Committee discuss what punishment the University is contemplating when it makes official statements such as "faculty who move class away from picket lines may be disciplined."
In response to a question, Professor Balas suggested the Committee not issue any statement on the strike because it should not get in the middle of the bargaining process. The Committee should, however, discuss with the Provost the language used about disciplining faculty members and what might be done. Committee members assented.
Faculty Input On Decisions About Classroom Configuration?
The Committee turned to the proposed design of the science-teaching-and-student-services building, which will replace the Science Classroom Building at the northeast end of the Washington Avenue Bridge. A number of Committee members expressed considerable dismay at the configuration and size of classrooms in the new building. (The current lecture auditoriums that seat 200+ students (4) and 70-seat classroom will be replaced with six smaller 117-seat interactive classrooms, six 90-seat interactive classrooms, and seven 30-seat seminar classrooms.) Department heads in IT have protested the configuration as not appropriate for their needs.
The question, Professor Windsor said, is how academics closest to a facility are integrated into the planning for that facility. She said this reminded her of the decision about the new CSOM/CLA building, decisions about which were made at a high level, not with the faculty.
With the budget model as it is, and many departments increasing class size, not reducing it, the new lay out seems counterintuitive.
She expressed concern that the right hand doesn't always pay attention to what the left hand is doing. She observed that she teaches a large 3-XXX lecture course, including in the Science Classroom Building, that is a prerequisite to other more advanced courses, and if they cannot find enough lecture halls to teach large numbers of introductory students, the students don't have the prerequisites for other courses, and their progress in the major is stymied. "So much for 5-year graduation rates in that case." Professor Durfee commented in an email on the subject that perhaps someday classroom design planning would be done in collaboration with faculty, perhaps through the Academy of Distinguished Teachers, so that issues of classroom size and what constitutes an "interactive classroom" have faculty input.
The Committee agreed it would raise questions about the new facility with the Provost next week.
Is BigU Still a Land-Grant Institution?
The Board of Regents has seen the data on the increasing qualifications of incoming freshmen, Professor Wambach said, and a couple of Board members have asked how far the University can push on increasing the high-school rank metric. What will be the tradeoffs if 90% of the students are in the top 10% of their class? Is that a realistic or politically-desirable goal? Some Board members, Professor Balas added, suggested that this may be the wrong metric; the University is a public, land-grant institution and it should seek to educate students from many parts of society. The Provost, however, has said that the University will continue to use as a metric the academic quality of incoming students.
Metrics
Professor Balas turned next to the question of metrics and measurement, a major topic of discussion at the retreat in late August. He reported that he took away points from the September Regents' meeting that made him realize this is an issue about which the Committee must be assertive. One of the Board members focused on the comparison group: who does the University want to be like, and why. Tracking metrics generates policies; if the University is tracking something, why?
The Committee, he concluded, must disregard the advice it received at the retreat not to worry about the metrics and measurements, because they will clearly have an effect on decisions and policies.
Committee members made it clear at the retreat, Professor Martin commented, that they are not happy about the metrics currently being used.
(Professor Balas observed that there is only one metric related to research in the current set: dollars.)
Professor Sirc said he talked to Dr. Howard, Director of Institutional Research, about what would be the single best measure to improve the University's rankings; Dr. Howard said it would be to improve the graduation rate. It is not clear what any individual faculty member can do about that. In the case of his department, it has sought to hire new and interesting faculty but has been told that will not happen.
One can measure and re-measure, Professor Windsor said, but unless one identifies what is driving any comparative advantage, the measures don't by themselves help achieve outcomes. What is it that higher-ranked universities do, she asked? For example, do they have lower student-faculty ratios, do faculty teach fewer/more classes, do they admit students with better academic records, do they provide more/different advising support, do they recruit more outstanding faculty, do they have better retention mechanisms for faculty and staff, etc.? Knowing these types of pivot points would help to identify where resources might be directed.
Professor Martin commented, apropos Professor Windsor's point, that they have known for a long time that Minnesota's faculty is 20% smaller than the faculty of its peers given the number of students. It appears that CLA faculty teach more students per faculty member than other CIC liberal arts colleges, for example. Of all the discussion about getting into the top three, she has only heard one part of the University say it needs more faculty: the AHC has been forthright in saying it needs an additional 500. The rest of the University does not make that kind of statement because there would be no place to house them if they could be hired. It is an odd ambition to be really good without the wherewithal to get there.
What is excellence, Professor Balas asked? Professor Windsor responded that some would say one knows it when one sees it; departments are just excellent. His concern, Professor Balas said, is that the Regents are set on metrics and measures, and if there is nothing there about teaching and scholarship, they will be lost in the message. He said he would prefer that the Board not just talk about metrics but have a much richer conversation about what it takes to make the University great. If there were three additional metrics that would be easy to measure and that would go beyond what is being proposed, what would they be, Professor Yust asked? The University collects a lot of data; there must be some that say something about faculty excellence.
Professor Martin urged that Professors Balas and Hoover bring up the concerns about metrics in their meeting with the chair and vice chair of the Board of Regents and convey the faculty discomfort with metrics that are missing important parts of faculty activities. And that do not correspond to faculty perceptions of what it means to be a top-three university, Professor Balas added. It is the faculty's sense that other things are going on that matter but that are not measured. To the extent that Institutional Research is disconnected from the academic mission, Professor Martin said, the faculty will not see what they believe appropriate in the metrics. That is why Professor Balas is correct, Professor Kane said: the Committee must take an active role in identifying what it believes should be measured.
Professor Wambach asked if it mattered "what most of us do or what a few of us do." The University has 45 National Academy members; its peers have 65 or more. So what the University needs to do is hire 25 National Academy members who will bring a lot of grant money and reputations. That would solve the problem without worrying about the rest of the 3000 faculty. Or hire three Nobel Prize winners, Professor Martin added. The metrics reward the star system, Professor Wambach maintained. People are brought in after they have established their reputation; schools with high reputations recruit stars. That is why the Committee should develop metrics it can embrace, Professor Balas said, because the star system is divisive; do some get everything and the rest nothing? Its metrics should be ones the Committee believes are right and the discussion should start with them.
Communication
Up to now the Committee has been a strong advocate but it and the administration have been two ships passing in the night, Professor Balas commented.
Things have not changed this year; sometimes he (a department head), as a member of this Committee, knows more than his dean, but sometimes his dean knows things that he would have expected to know as a member of this Committee. The faculty generally are clueless about many things; they know that budgets are increasing but that costs are up 10% so that the departments must make cuts.
Professor Yust said it has been her sense that Minnesota has been among the most consultative institutions; in the past there was one person responsible for certain kinds of decisions and one could call that person to get an answer. Now responsibility is diffused over a number of people and it is difficult to identify responsibility.
A lot of faculty were involved in strategic positioning, Professor Martin observed, but they are no longer. The Provost created a culture of consultation with the task forces that has since diminished.
The Committee should have a conversation with the Provost to express its views that the measures the colleges are being held to do not fit what faculty do and that the process as constructed did not have enough academic participation.
There was so much time and money spent on the task forces, Professor Yust said, and the disconnect between their work and what has happened may lie with whomever was charged to carry out the recommendations. One question is the extent to which those obligated to carry out the recommendations were also obliged to consult.

