… in the Minneapolis Star Tribune notes that the most charitable description of what’s been going on at the clubby University of Minnesota medical school would be “bizarre.”
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
American Medical Schools Are
"Only In It for the Money" Say Their Faculty
Oh, my, God....
One of my medical school heroes, Dr. Roy Poses, writes in Healthcare Renewal:
We recently discussed the plight of young medical faculty. It appears that their plight is even worse than we imagined.
Last month, an abstract was presented at the Annual Conference on Research in Medical Education at the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Medical Colleges, in a session entitled "Your Career is More than Your Specialty." The citation would be: Pololi L, Ash A, Krupat E. Faculty Values in the Culture of Academic Medicine: Findings of a National Faculty Survey.
The authors described a large survey, of over 5000 faculty at 26 US nationally representative medical schools, done as part of the National Initiative on Gender, Culture, and Leadership in Medicine (known as C ‐ Change) project. The overall response rate was good (53%). Here are the striking results:
51% agreed that 'the administration is only interested in me for the revenue I generate'; 31%; that 'the culture of my institution discourages altruism'; 31%, that other people have taken credit for my work'; and 30% that 'I am reluctant to express my opinion for fear of negative consequences.' Half perceived that the institution does not value teaching and 27% that it does not reward clinical excellence; Over half disagreed with the statement that their own values are aligned with those of the institution. Also, 30% had seriously considered leaving academic medicine and 46% their own institution, both in the prior year.
These results show that US medical education is in moral crisis, and probably close to catastrophe. These results should provoke shame and outrage, and cause widespread discussion.
On Health Care Renewal, we have discussed evidence, mostly anecdotal, about the rot within the foundations of medicine and health care. (Note, posts on conflicts of interest, often affecting medical school faculty and leadership, are here; we have posted about how academic medicine has often allowed suppression and manipulation of research; posts on excessive compensation of health care executives, including those of academic institutions, not based on upholding the academic mission are here.) Now it appears that the rot is so severe that the whole edifice is about to fall down.
Meanwhile, the academic leaders who have personally profited from and colluded with the transformation of the system into one that is only in it for the money should resign. The few remaining leaders will need to draw upon all their honesty, integrity, knowledge, and determination to rebuild the system.
Finally, shame on all of us for letting us get to this place.
Amen, Dr. Poses.
at 11:37 AM